I make my own aftershave with Witch Hazel and love it. In an 8oz jar, I mix
3.5 oz grain alcohol (i.e. everclear)
3.5 oz witch hazel
16 drops glycerin (moisterizer)
150 drops essential oils
Shake well and enjoy.
I never make the same batch twice, but the EOs i usually use are bay rum, lavender, bergamont, peppermint, lime, rosemary, and clove.
The WH really tightens the pores after a hot shave with a brush and puck of shaving soap – old school.